Tuesday, January 10, 2006

A Disturbance in the Force

So here's the thing:

I'm surprised Caleb didn't beat me to this, but then he's a company man now, and may have obligations.

This morning Steve Jobs announced the first Intel Macs. The important thing to know about Macintosh computers with Intel processors is that they will be able to run Windows software. Not only is being able to dual boot (run either operating system when you turn it on) with Windows a virtual guarantee, unless the brains over at Apple are completely devoid of gray matter they are going to facilitate the running of Windows programs within the OS X environment. They might even go as far as to implement the full Win32 specification (and thereby emulate the Windows API). Even if they don't, there's always the open source community, who seem to be well on their way to accomplishing just that. Even if none of this happens, now that Macs run on x86, you'll see a lot more applications and games available on that platform because it's much easier (and therefore cheaper) to port x86 to x86 than PowerPC, thus kick-starting the chicken-and-egg problem with Mac software developement.

The very idea that there is a computer out there which is capable of dual--nay--triple (Win/Mac/Linux) booting is enough to make any computer nerd salavate. And what beauties they are! In particular, the MacBook Pro. This elegant flower of a machine is built on Intel's latest warhorse of a processor, the Core Duo which is the first 65 nanometer transistor processor. Two cores running at 1.83 GHz: *drool* *swoon* Oh, the power!

Ahem. The problem here is the price. This latest toy could be mine in February for a measly $2299. Yes, that's 200 lower than the price quoted on the Apple website. I have my connections. But is it really worth all that money? Well, to find out, I headed over to Dell to see what was on the market. Here is a system which I deem to be comparable to the MacBook Pro:

ModelInspiron 9300MacBook Pro
Operating SystemWindows XP Media Center EditionOS X v10.4 Tiger
Processor1.83 GHz/667Mhz FSB Intel Core Duo Processor1.83 GHz/667Mhz FSB Intel Core Duo Processor
Display17" Widescreen 1440x90015.4" Widescreen 1440x900
Memory1GB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 667MHz (2 Dimms) 1GB (single SODIMM) 667MHz DDR2 SDRAM (PC2-5300)
Hard Drive100GB 5400RPM SATA100GB 5400RPM SATA
Graphics Card256MB NVIDA GeForce Go 7800ATI Mobility Radeon X1600 with 256MB of GDDR3 SDRAM and dual-link DVI
Optical Drive8x CD/DVD burner (DVD+/-RW) with double-layer DVD+R write capabilitySlot-load SuperDrive (DVD±RW/CD-RW)
WirelessIntel PRO/Wireless 3945 802.11a/g Mini Card (54Mbps)Built-in 54-Mbps AirPort Extreme (802.11g); built-in Bluetooth 2.0+EDR
Battery53 WHr 6-cell Lithium Ion Primary Battery60 WHr Lithium-polymer battery
RemoteWindows Media Center RemoteApple Remote
  • Microsoft Works Suite 2006- Includes Mocrosoft Word plus more (I have access to a full copy of Office 2003 for $16 if I want it.)
These are free:
  • Have you ever heard of the Google Pack? Firefox, Picasa, Desktop Search, etc.
  • OpenOffice.org is all you really need for basic office Apps.

  • Mac OS X v10.4.4 Tiger (includes Spotlight, Dashboard, Mail, iChat AV, Safari, Address Book, QuickTime, iCal, DVD Player, Xcode Developer Tools)
  • Life ’06 (includes iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie HD, iDVD, iWeb, GarageBand), Microsoft Office 2004 for Mac Test Drive, iWork ’06 (30-day trial), QuickBooks for Mac New User Edition, Comic Life, FileMaker Pro trial, Omni Outliner
  • Photo Booth
  • Front Row
  • Price available to me (before tax, including shipping)$1,698.12$2,299.00

    Notice that last row: price. There is a $600 difference between the two. I know this is a Mac and it's new and shiny and all, but six hundred bucks? I could buy the Dell and then if I really needed to get my Mac fix I'd have money left over for a decently-equipped Mac Mini ($564: G4-1.42GHz, 512MB, 80GB). Oh, sure, the Mac has fancy doo-dads like a backlit keyboard, a built-in webcam, and magnetic snap-off power cable to prevent tripping, plus it's smaller and lighter, but I actually prefer the bigger screen and I don't care about the weight. The Dell is also upgradeable to a faster processor, a higher resolution display, and an 80 WHr battery. The only Apple upgrade that looked tempting was the 120GB Hard Drive for $92 extra. And what's with the one-button Touch Pad? I don't want to have to pull out my mouse on a plane.

    I don't really need a new computer at the moment. My current Dell Inspiron 8200 serves me more than adequately with the exception of hard drive space. I only have a 40GB drive, but I've been offloading large files to an external backup drive and to Athena (my trusty Linux server) when I don't need them.

    So I've decided to wait. Wait for the hype to go away, wait for the price to come down, wait for the next generation of features, wait for the higher-resolution 17" model, wait for clarification on Windows app compatability/porting.

    I'm not really the early adopter type. By the time I'm in the market a lot of interesting things might be happening in the computer intustry. Microsoft's Vista is supposed to (finally) come out, and then there's the whole Blu-Ray/HD-DVD format war.


    1. I can't say who this is but I could get you a bigger discount then the one you quoted. Yes there is a 600 dollar price difference. But you failed to mention the difference in included software as well. iLife '06 gives you near professional level Video and Audio editing capabilities built into your system. Lets also not forget about the stability and security premium that you might be willing to pay. And they are cooler. Lets face it Apple has become a premium product. You are paying for the name.

    2. Erm, yes, all that you said. But magnetic snap-off power cable? That's coooooooooooool.

    3. Oh and about the right clicking. First of all how much right clicking do you do geez. Second, all you have to do is press the comand/open apple key and click to get the same result. Not too dificult for you I hope.

    4. I went through and did the price comparison myself. To get a comparable system from dell it runs $2341. That system has Bluetooth
      The widescreen display
      CD DVD DL burner
      100gb HD
      1.83ghz Core Duo

      Your prices seem to be off

    5. "Your prices seem to be off"

      I have my connections. I'm basing my comparisons on the prices available to me personally.

    6. Another reason to hold off has been brought to my attention: apparently OS X Tiger is optimized for 64-bit computing.

      I'm honestly not sure what the power (and therefore also heat) ramifications are of a 64-bit dual-core mobile processors (probably because they won't become commercially available until late this year). It could end up being the best thing since sliced bread, and the key to coninuing the trend of doubling computing power every 18 months, or it could be a bad idea that needs loads of research in battery and cooling technology to become economically feasable on a consumer notebook PC without the inclusion of a jet engine fan and a car battery.

      In any case, I fully expect to see within a year dual core Intel 64-bit desktop models, followed six months later by the notebook versions. In fact Apple and Intel may be timing their release to coencide with Vista.

    7. I right click all. the. time.

    8. I chat is pretty nice and helps conversation. When you start typing something, it gives your screenname a thought bubble. :) Macs are pretty.

    9. Macs are just way to cool to not buy.... once you go mac you'll never go back... Another thing you forgot to mention is the ability to triple boot.... Can the dell triple boot? .... Actually I don't even know... can they? Well I don't think they can so for the sake of argument they can't so there.

      Oh and about the clicking deal.... I have a friend who has a macbook and he has a program that allows you to both right and left click when booted in windows.

      Plus macs are pretty.... I like that one! I wholeheartedly agree!!!